Hm. Both appear to be evenly matched.
I would have to go with Panda, though, because the avatar seems like a goddess in a way.

Nightmare looks more deadly. I think she would win.

Nightmare.

Star.
Flying things always have an advantage.

Devlyn. Evil ftw.

Dev

Ultima easily.

Layner, probably.

Ultima would kick some ASS! Lol.

I think Ultima's got this~

Ginger would probably be the victor owo

Ultima would definitely win... That avi is badass!

Shenandoah. Because Shenandoah is simply fantastic <3

I get the feeling Shen's attire is even MORE impractical in battle than Hermes (no matter now sexy rawr). so Hermes wins. Besides he's got a big staff and just stick it through her without having to reach too far.

*loves on Hermes and shoots Juri a grin* I'm gonna say Hermes, because he's got gold on his avi and I likes gold.

Completely impractical, I know, but... oh well!