Hmmm, Espy.

Ultima - metal freezes...fast...

I am curious as to how this works...I did not see a weapon on Espy or Alpha...? (I know, it's opinion, but the last few have me confused...)

Ultima would be my bet. Those frosty-freeze-y magicks would undoubtedly win out against your gun/sword and stranded island-ed-ness.

kilala
that bag maybe magical

Hyjin. Because that is one BIG sword.

Ulty -- To be honest, Hyjin looks a tad bit clumsy, and Ulty could probably shoot off several ice attacks before he could even move.

Ultima - again, ice + metal + skin = frostbite

(Ignore this post in terms of the game. I just need to mention -- wearing a gauntlet with nothing under it seems like a very silly idea. In practice, I personally would have a leather glove under the gauntlet so my skin isn't directly in contact with the metal. In my RPC's case, the hand under the gauntlet isn't quite /human/, soooo.)

If we're ignoring Espy's post, then Lawtan o3o

Whisper with the wrench in the kitchen

Hy. It's the sword.

Hyjin. He has less stuff weighing him down, and looks more skilled.

Ultima... I think coz of the magic swirling around her.

Cazzidy - awesome pirate queen wins automatically!

Probably Law. Magic could probably beat firearms.