...Hm, a hint, huh?

I really have no clue right now as for yours.

Taylor
(I thinks I know Natsu's)

Oh, Then what is it ulti ? :3

And umm bill ewe

Michael

*throws confetti every where and nods* YAY YOU GOT IT :3

Ester.

There are only so many common M names that don't start with Ma--

Nope.

Imma guess Espy is a drew

I guess ... Jazz x3x;

@Natsu: That's what I was going to guess XP

Am I guessing Ulty's middle name?

Ashe >.>

Since you know my first, yes you are XD

I guess ... Evan owo

Chloe

(fail logic = because I taught of Cleopatra as the avatar and modernised it kinda but not) OH MAN MINE WILL BE PRETTY HARD O.o

Krishna o3o (tries to think outside of the box because you said it would be hard XD)

Xander.

(Hill...? /shot)

Tasmin